Information on Maine Hall of Fame inducties does not show if they were inducted for Player or Organizer.
| 2006 | No Election |
| 2005 | |
| 2004 | Steve Frost P/O |
| 2003 | Gorden Carpenter |
| 2003 | Bo Cobb |
| 2002 | Carol Simpson |
| 2001 | No Election |
| 2000 | No Election |
| 1999 | David Gallant |
| 1998 | No Election |
| 1997 | Info Not Availible. |
| 1996 | Info Not Availible. |
| 1995 | Info Not Availible. |
| 1994 | Info Not Availible. |
| 1993 | Info Not Availible. |
| 1992 | Info Not Availible. |
| 1991 | Info Not Availible. |
| 1990 | Info Not Availible |
| 1989 | Fred Sibley |
| 1988 | Jane York |
| 1988 | Carl York |
| 1987 | Clinton Simmons |
| 1986 | Merrill Bertrand Barns |
| 1986 | Douglas Edward Kienia |
| 1986 | Stanley S. Bisbee |
| 1985 | Anita Reid Pateneaude |
| 1985 | Wesley Elvin Pateneaude |
| 1984 | Clyde F. Hewett |
| 1984 | Rosaire Lefty Tardiff |
| 1984 | Roland Joseph Boudreault |
| 1983 | Harry Reid |
| 1983 | Albert Turner Allen |
| 1983 | Esidore J. Gallant |
| 1983 | Dominic Louie Pepin |
| 1982 | Ralph Robinson |
| 1982 | Robert Euclide Sirois |
| 1982 | Charles William Wood |
| 1981 | Bryce York |
| 1980 | Robert E. Harriman |
| 1979 | Lionel Lee Cameron |
| 1978 | Albert Lord |
| 1978 | Joseph James Davis |
| 1977 | Willard Scribner |
| 1977 | Dwight McVane |
| 1976 | Paul Clifton Tobey |
| 1976 | Emily O. Wood |
| 1976 | Roger W. Bolduc |
| 1975 | Robert Griffing |
| 1975 | Porter Clark |
| 1974 | Harold E. Goodier |
| 1974 | Raymond Adams |
| 1973 | Otto Whitney |
| 1972 | Charles Gerrish |